Do Lawyers Take Cases They Can’t Win

Do Lawyers Take Cases They Can’t Win

Stepping into a courtroom or negotiating a settlement is never a guaranteed win for any lawyer. Legal processes are complex, with outcomes depending on countless variables, many of which are beyond anyone’s control. 

This leads to an important question many people ask when considering legal representation: Do lawyers take cases they can't win? 

The answer is not as straightforward as it might seem. To understand why lawyers sometimes take on challenging cases, it’s essential to investigate the factors they consider, the ethical responsibilities they must uphold, and the strategies they use to approach tough legal battles.

Get A Free Consultation Today!

How Lawyers Decide to Take a Case

Lawyers don’t simply consider whether a case is an "easy win " when deciding whether to take it on. The decision is far more nuanced and based on thoughtful analysis. 

Here are some of the main factors lawyers consider before agreeing to represent a client:

Evaluating the merits of the case

The first step any lawyer takes is to evaluate the facts and legal merits of the case. They will carefully analyze the available evidence, including documents, testimonies, and relevant laws. 

For example, in personal injury cases, this might involve reviewing accident reports, medical records, and witness statements to determine whether negligence can be established.

Some cases present clear legal arguments, while others rest on weaker evidence and less definitive claims. Lawyers weigh whether the facts can realistically support the legal arguments needed to persuade a judge or jury. 

However, even if the evidence isn’t overwhelmingly strong, lawyers can still choose to move forward based on other factors.

Assessing potential risks vs. rewards

Another key factor is the potential outcome of the case versus the risks involved. For instance, if pursuing a claim involves significant legal fees, time, and emotional strain for a client, a lawyer may advise against it—even if there's a chance of winning. 

Alternatively, if the potential compensation or resolution is substantial, a lawyer might decide that the rewards outweigh the risks.

The client's goals

Lawyers also take time to understand the goals and motivations behind a lawsuit. For some clients, winning isn’t just about financial compensation; it might be about accountability or justice. Lawyers consider whether achieving the client’s desired outcome is possible. 

Even if the odds of success are slim, they might still take on a case if they believe the fight serves a greater purpose for the client or society.

Impact on legal precedent

Cases that seem unwinnable on the surface may still have broader implications for the legal system. Lawyers may take cases unlikely to succeed in challenging existing laws or set new legal precedents. 

These cases can be pivotal in driving legal reform or addressing critical issues.

Personal belief in the cause

For some lawyers, taking on a case comes from personal belief and passion. If a lawyer strongly believes in the righteousness of a client's position, they might accept the case despite significant obstacles. They may feel morally obligated to give the client a voice or bring attention to an injustice.

Ethical responsibilities in accepting cases

Lawyers operate under strict ethical obligations guiding whether they accept or decline a case. Their professional conduct is governed by rules that ensure fairness, accountability, and justice for all parties involved.

Avoiding frivolous cases

Lawyers are ethically bound to avoid bringing frivolous cases to court. A frivolous case is one without any foundation in fact or law, and pursuing such claims can clog the legal system and waste valuable resources. Before taking a case, a lawyer must believe there’s a reasonable chance of success or a legitimate question of law that deserves attention.

Honesty and transparency

Lawyers must be honest with their clients about their case's potential challenges and risks. They cannot provide false assurances or guarantee outcomes. If a lawyer believes a case has little chance of success, they must inform the client before taking on their representation. This transparency helps clients make informed decisions about how to proceed.

Serving the client's best interests

Once a lawyer agrees to take on a case, they must act in their client’s best interests. This includes being honest about the case's progress, advising on realistic expectations, and pursuing all possible strategies to achieve a favorable outcome.

Balancing justice and advocacy

While lawyers are advocates for their clients, they are also officers of the court, meaning they have a responsibility to uphold the integrity of the legal system. This balance requires lawyers to approach even the most challenging cases with professionalism and respect for the rule of law.

How Lawyers Approach Tough Cases

Taking on a challenging case doesn’t mean giving up or accepting defeat. Lawyers are trained to strategically handle adversity and find creative solutions to strengthen their client’s position. 

Here are some of the methods they use to tackle tough cases:

Thorough investigation

The foundation of any successful legal strategy is a comprehensive investigation. Lawyers leave no stone unturned as they gather evidence, interview witnesses, and consult with experts in relevant fields. Even when a case seems weak, new information can come to light that changes the outlook entirely.

For instance, finding a previously undiscovered surveillance video or medical testimony in a personal injury case could significantly bolster the claim. Similarly, uncovering inconsistencies in the opposing party’s story can create doubts that work in the client's favor.

Building a strong narrative

Cases are often won or lost based on the story presented to a judge or jury. Lawyers invest substantial effort into crafting a compelling narrative that highlights the key facts, legal principles, and emotional stakes involved in the case. This narrative isn’t just about presenting the evidence but about making it resonate with the decision-makers.

Aggressive negotiation

Many cases are resolved through negotiations rather than going to trial. Lawyers use strategic pressure to urge the opposing party to settle on terms favorable to their client. When legal odds aren't in their favor, they may still achieve success by emphasizing the risks and costs the other side faces if the case goes to court.

Creative problem-solving

Challenging cases often require creative legal thinking. This might involve finding alternative legal theories, citing lesser-known case law, or using procedural tactics to gain an advantage. By thinking outside the box, lawyers can uncover opportunities others might overlook.

Preparation for every scenario

Every lawyer knows that preparation is key to handling complex cases. They anticipate potential arguments from the opposing side, prepare counterarguments and ensure their case is as polished and credible as possible. Detailed preparation can make even an uphill battle seem more manageable.

Persistence and resilience

Challenging cases require determination and a refusal to back down in the face of adversity. Lawyers willing to go the extra mile for their clients often make the difference, even when the odds may seem unfavorable. Their persistence can lead to unexpected breakthroughs or settlements.

Why Some Lawyers Are Willing to Take Risks

Taking complex cases benefits not only individual clients but also the legal profession. Lawyers who take calculated risks and represent clients in challenging situations help ensure everyone has access to justice, regardless of their circumstances. 

Sometimes, these cases bring about systemic change or set legal precedents that protect others in the future.

On a personal level, standing up for a client in the face of adversity can be deeply rewarding. Knowing they made a difference, even in a difficult situation, motivates many lawyers to tackle tough cases.

The Role of Public Perception in 'Unwinnable' Cases

Public perception can surprisingly impact whether lawyers take on cases that seem difficult or even impossible to win. While the courtroom is meant to be a space where facts and laws prevail, the opinions of the public and the media often play a significant role in shaping the direction and outcome of certain cases. 

Understanding this influence can be a factor for lawyers in deciding whether to pursue a legal battle that might otherwise appear unwinnable.

Building momentum through awareness

Some cases resonate with the public in ways that extend beyond a courtroom. When a legal issue involves widespread social or political implications, public support can create momentum that encourages lawyers to take on challenging cases. 

For example, many civil rights cases initially faced an uphill battle in terms of legal precedent, but public attention brought the injustices to light. This widespread support often strengthened these cases, helping to bring about meaningful legal and social change.

Consider cases tied to whistleblowing or corporate accountability. When the media shines a spotlight on a courageous individual standing up to a large institution, public sympathy can counterweight powerful legal opposition. 

Even in cases with slim prospects of winning, public interest can pressure defendants or larger entities to settle or concede some ground.

Pressure on opposing parties

Public perception doesn’t just influence the case itself; it can also apply pressure to the opposing side. A company facing significant backlash due to negative press may choose to settle a case rather than risk further damage to its reputation. 

Similarly, government agencies or institutions often have to consider public opinion when deciding whether to proceed aggressively in cases where public outrage is growing. For lawyers, understanding this dynamic could provide an avenue to achieve resolutions that might not have been possible without public scrutiny.

For instance, widespread coverage can push a negligent company to act more quickly to resolve claims in personal injury cases involving unsafe products. Fear of reputational harm often becomes a motivating factor in avoiding prolonged litigation, even if the company initially intended to fight in court.

Shifting the narrative through media stories

How a case is presented to the public can shift narratives and alter perceptions, which may ultimately influence the legal process. Lawyers sometimes work with their clients to ensure their stories are heard, helping to humanize the issues at the heart of the legal matter. 

A sympathetic plaintiff’s story, presented well in public forums, can draw attention to unfair treatment, negligence, or systemic problems.

For example, cases involving medical malpractice or wrongful death often gain traction when people relate to the details personally. 

A well-told story about the struggles and pain caused by a hospital's negligence can create waves of support, even before the court decides the case. This added layer of pressure can make defendants more likely to offer fair settlements or reconsider their positions.

Amplifying unheard voices

Many lawyers take on potentially unwinnable cases because they believe in amplifying the voices of those who may not otherwise have access to justice. Public perception often provides these individuals or groups with a platform that the legal system alone might not offer. 

Even if a case fails to succeed in court, the awareness it generates can spark larger conversations and motivate others to act, sometimes leading to policy changes or reforms.

Whether it’s a class-action lawsuit against an environmental offender or a workplace discrimination case, public opinion can transform what was initially a one-person fight into a movement for justice. 

Some cases, while not necessarily "winners" on paper, can still leave an enduring impact by galvanizing others to demand change.

The intersection of law and public perception reminds us that the courtroom is not always the final stage for justice. Some battles are won—not just with evidence and arguments—but by harnessing the power of a public willing to stand behind the cause.

The Levin Firm’s Commitment to Justice

At the end of the day, choosing the right lawyer can make all the difference in your case, even if it seems like an uphill battle. At The Levin Firm, we are committed to pursuing justice for our clients with unmatched dedication and preparation. 

Our team takes each case seriously, focusing on personalized attention and a bold, results-driven approach to advocacy.

If you’re facing a legal challenge and need someone who will fight for you at every juncture, contact The Levin Firm for a free consultation at (215) 825-5183. Together, we’ll work toward achieving the best possible outcome for your case.

Get A Free Consultation Today!